07 July 2026

Someone understands the Social Policy Bond principle!

Kylie Mohr writes: 

As prediction markets boom and a new wildfire season begins, fire survivors and ethicists say that the betting encourages and rewards callous thinking — and dangerous behavior, too. One major concern stemming from wildfire prediction markets is arson. ...Theoretically, making a bet could give someone the perverse incentive to start a fire, or help one grow. Unlike other disasters, such as hurricanes, flooding or extreme heat, a fire can be manipulated in minutes by just one person. “Systems that tie financial gain to wildfire outcomes risk encouraging misuse, including arson, and are not compatible with our mission,” a spokesperson for the U.S. Forest Service said. Will betting on wildfires lead to arson?, Kylie Mohr, 29 June 2026

This is how Social Policy Bonds were conceived: define an uncertain future event and allow people to bet on whether it will occur or not. If enough people bet enough money, they will have an incentive to co-operate to make that event happen. Simple. Social Policy Bonds would target desirable social and environmental goals. Though some bondholders would be mere speculators, others would be motivated by the prospect of potential increases in the value of their bonds, to help achieve the targeted goal. The aim is to channel people's self-interest - their wish to win a bet - into improving society's well-being. Targeted goals have to be chosen carefully. A bond regime would show the most marked improvement over conventional policy when: goals are long term; when current policy is failing; and when diverse, adaptive approaches will be necessary. I've written about applying them to goals that fulfil all these criteria: including eliminating conflict, reducing crime, unemployment or climate change. Each goal must ideally be objectively verifiable. Though the non-tradeable variant of my idea is currently being implemented in about 25 countries, the original conception has yet to be tried. One possibility could be target for reduction the area of land lost to wildfire in, say, the United States, in one year....

No comments:

Post a Comment